• Re: What is unique about David Coffaro wines?

  • Thomas Mercer-Hursh, November 24, 1998

    To me, the first thing I think of when I think of a Coffaro wine is not so much a specific taste aspect as it is Dave as master blender.  There are those, of course, who seem to think that the best wine can only ever be one grape from one vineyard, but these are obviously people unfamiliar with Bordeaux!  Just as I think the magic of Bordeaux is a combination of the specific terroir and the bringing together of complementary flavors from multiple grapes to create a whole that is better than any parts, I think Dave achieves what he does because of his mastery of blending.  Unlike
    Bordeaux, where there is a relatively common concept of the desired result, Dave works a much broader palette, focusing at one point on bringing a predominantly Zin base to perfect expression, then shifting to another concept altogether for the Estate Cuvee or whatever.  Unlike wines and spirits that are blended for consistency, I see each of these as pursuing an individual unique concept, a concept coming in some cases from the predominant grape and some cases from the character of a set of grapes (e.g., Estate vs. Neighbors), but in each case working with the core concept to find a combination which allows each to become the best expression of that concept.

    > From this core, I think other qualities follow.

    * Minimal new oak because that would mask the qualities of the grapes themselves.
    * Wine characterized by a high degree of balance, even when young
    * Well rounded wines with flavor at all points in the tasting
    * Rich wines (you don't have a sound system like that and not turn it up!)

    =========================================================================
    Thomas Mercer-Hursh, Ph.D                     email: thomas@cintegrity.com
    Computing Integrity, Inc.                           sales: 510-233-9329
    550 Casey Drive - Cypress Point              support: 510-233-9327
    Point Richmond, CA 94801-3751             fax: 510-233-6950
     

    REPLY TO THIS MESSAGE   START A NEW THREAD
     

    • What is unique about David Coffaro wines?

    • Everett Bandman, November 21, 1998
      • Re: What is unique about David Coffaro wines?

      • Thomas Mercer-Hursh, November 24, 1998
        • Re: What is unique about David Coffaro wines?

        • Everett Bandman, November 25, 1998
          • Re: What is unique about David Coffaro wines?

          • Thomas Mercer-Hursh, Ph.D., November 27, 1998
            • Re: What is unique about David Coffaro wines?

            • Everett Bandman, Ph.D., November 27, 1998
              • Re: What is unique about David Coffaro wines?

              • Thomas Mercer-Hursh, Ph.D., December 8, 1998
                • Re: What is unique about David Coffaro wines?

                • Everett Bandman, December 11, 1998


    RETURN